When you file an insurance claim, most people assume the first number they receive is fair.
In reality, the first offer is often just a starting point.
Insurance adjusters operate within authority limits and internal review structures. The initial offer may not reflect the full value of what your policy allows. Many policyholders don’t realize they have the right to question how the number was calculated — or that additional review can change the outcome.
Here’s what typically happens after you submit a claim:
-
An adjuster is assigned
-
The damage is evaluated
-
The policy is reviewed
-
A payment estimate is created
Then an offer is made.
Because most people accept that first offer, many claims never move beyond the initial level of review.
Common Claim Handling Issues Policyholders Should Watch For
1. Fast settlement pressure
“We can issue payment today if you sign.”
Quick payment can be tempting after a loss, but fast settlements sometimes come before a full valuation is complete. Once a release is signed, reopening the claim can be difficult.
2. Aggressive depreciation
Insurance companies may apply depreciation in ways that reduce payouts significantly. The key question is whether the valuation method matches the policy language and state law.
3. Coverage confusion
Policy wording is complex. A statement that something is “not covered” should always be backed by a specific policy citation — not just a verbal explanation.
4. Delays and repeated documentation requests
Sometimes claims stall because of missing paperwork. Other times, delays can simply wear policyholders down. Persistent follow-up is essential.
Understanding Adjuster Authority
Adjusters often have financial authority limits. Larger payouts may require supervisor approval or additional review. When a claim escalates, it moves up the internal ladder — and that can change the conversation.
Policyholders are allowed to ask for escalation.
A calm request such as:
“I’d like a supervisor to review this estimate.”
is completely appropriate and often effective.
How to Respond to a Low Offer
Never accept an offer you don’t understand.
Instead, ask:
“Can you walk me through how you calculated this number?”
Take notes. Request documentation. Compare their numbers to real-world replacement costs.
Helpful evidence includes:
-
Receipts
-
Current market pricing
-
Contractor repair estimates
-
Photographs of the damage
-
Independent inspections
The more documentation you provide, the harder it is to undervalue the claim.
Key Questions Every Policyholder Can Ask
-
Can I see the exact policy language supporting this decision?
-
Can I have a full itemized breakdown of the estimate?
-
What depreciation schedule was applied?
-
Who reviewed this valuation?
Transparency is not optional — insurers are required to justify their decisions.
When Additional Help May Be Needed
Some policyholders choose to hire a public adjuster or an attorney to represent their interests. Public adjusters work on contingency and negotiate directly with the insurance company. Attorneys may become involved when a claim is denied, delayed, or underpaid.
Every situation is different, but outside advocacy can change the balance of power when negotiations stall.
The Bottom Line
Insurance is a contract.
You paid premiums in exchange for protection. A claim is not a favor — it is the moment the contract is supposed to work.
The first offer is not always the final offer. It’s often the beginning of a negotiation.
Policyholders who ask questions, demand documentation, and push for full review are far more likely to receive payments that reflect the true value of their coverage.
And when the process stops being fair, experienced legal help matters.
The Voss Law Firm represents commercial property owners nationwide, helping them navigate complex insurance claims, challenge underpayments, and enforce their policy rights. Our team focuses exclusively on protecting policyholders — not insurance companies — and we work to level the playing field so businesses recover what they are contractually owed after a loss.
