A Gold Mine For Scammers
Updated: May 8, 2011 - 8:18 AM
With precious metal prices surging, telemarketers use misleading, and sometimes illegal, tactics to sell coins.
Linda Keith with her father, who bought coins from Barber Coins & Collectibles. Keith has filed complaints with police, the state and Hennepin County alleging that he was taken advantage of, as a vulnerable adult with mild dementia.
In three decades of investing in gold and silver, Dean Dellinger amassed nearly 27 pounds of coins.
His collection might have been worth more than $645,000 at current prices -- if he still had it. Instead, the 88-year-old Florida resident says his devotion to hard currencies made him an easy mark for a Minneapolis pitchman who cold-called and persuaded him to trade for a class of historic coins called "numismatics." Dellinger alleges in a federal lawsuit that he lost more than $335,000 on a series of swaps. "The guy just skinned me," he said.
As gold has surged as high as $1,556 an ounce, many investors are learning the hard way that the marketing of valuable coins is a largely unregulated trade in which shady and sometimes illegal practices abound. Unscrupulous telemarketers misrepresent coin values, sell counterfeits or persuade customers to finance purchases with reverse mortgages or retirement savings.
In Minnesota, the state attorney general's office is investigating a half dozen local and national firms. "This industry is somewhat like the Wild West," spokesman Ben Wogsland said.
Mass telemarketing of coins began in the Twin Cities in the mid-1970s, and the metro area is a hub of what has become a multibillion-dollar industry, with about 30 Minnesota firms pitching to an estimated half million serious collectors and investors nationwide.
Gary Adkins, an Edina dealer who was named Coin Dealer of the Year by the American Numismatic Association in August, says most firms are honest. But he acknowledged that some have persistent problems with fraud, theft and misrepresentation.
Adkins recalled examining some coins for an elderly Minnesota woman who took $250,000 from her savings and borrowed more to buy coins from a New Jersey dealer. The coins were worth about a quarter of what she paid, he said. "I hear these kinds of horror stories all the time."
Many dealers hire salesmen regardless of criminal convictions or drug, alcohol and mental problems -- providing they can deliver a sale. The successful ones can make six-figure annual incomes.
Investors rally around precious metals as a hedge against inflation, a refuge from political storms that periodically roil world economies. As a result, the price of gold has tripled since 2005, adjusted for inflation, while silver nearly doubled to $48.70 an ounce at its April 28 peak.
Such precious metals as gold, silver, platinum and palladium trade in several forms. Bars and uncirculated bullion coins sell at or slightly above the market price of their metallic content, while the more subjective valuation of numismatics and other collectible coins makes them more prone to abuse.
Coin buyers are often wealthy elderly people whom firms identify from closely guarded marketing lists. Yet the kinds of protections that have evolved over the years in markets for stocks and other securities generally don't apply to coins unless pitchmen stray from scripts that carefully avoid characterizing them as investments.
Dellinger made his trade for the numismatics with Martin Klevens, a salesman who called from the Minneapolis firm International Rarities. He remembers Klevens as a smooth talker with a preacher's knack for instilling trust.
He didn't know that Klevens -- known as "Party Marty" by some former associates -- had been sentenced in 1997 to 25 months in federal prison after admitting to defrauding at least four coin buyers out of more than $160,000.
No law bars a person with criminal convictions from the coin industry.
Klevens was sent to a half-way house in 1999 for violating the terms of his release by drinking alcohol. After walking away from the facility, he was sent back to prison for 10 months in 2000.
When he got out, International Rarities took him back. Dellinger, a World War II veteran and former lab foreman for American Cyanamid, said Klevens called a couple dozen times before he agreed to trade his bullion coins for numismatics.
He sued to try to recoup the $335,000 he alleges he lost on trades through International Rarities. But his attorney, Joe Zarzaur of Pensacola, Fla., said International Rarities has said it wouldn't even consider paying the damages they are seeking.
Neither Klevens nor David Marion, the owner of International Rarities, responded to requests for comment. Attorneys for the company have responded in court and denied any wrongdoing.
A growing problem?
It's impossible to say how widespread abuses are in the coin business. Minnesota's Commerce Department checks metal dealers' scales but otherwise has no oversight of such firms.
The Federal Trade Commission lumps coin complaints in with other art, gems and precious metals. That tally suggests a growing problem with Minnesota firms, with 19 complaints last year compared with an average of five in prior years. Last year, only California and Texas had more.
Roseville police detective Marc Schultz says he has fielded complaints from around the country about one firm, Reputable Rare Coins. "What I'm finding is that Minnesota is becoming the poster child for this rare-coin industry fraud," Schultz said in a recent interview. "A lot of these victims are saying, 'What's with these companies in Minnesota?'"
Experts say authorities never hear about most swindles, because those who get cheated eat their losses out of embarrassment or lack the money or records to file lawsuits.
Few lawyers will tackle the inherently complicated and expensive cases. It's hard to prove fraud, especially when elderly clients have memory problems or dementia.
But some consumers do fight back. Carlton Whetsel complained to the South Dakota attorney general after he had problems with Reputable Rare Coins.
The 71-year-old from Watertown, S.D., said in an interview that his troubles began five years earlier when he swapped some coins through Twin Cities Gold & Silver.
He said the salesman on that transaction, Anthony Kloiber, told him the coins were worth $68,800. But last year, when Whetsel went to swap them, he says he learned they were worth far less even though the price of gold had roughly doubled.
Kloiber has been civilly committed twice because of heroin and crack abuse and mental problems, and has convictions for theft and passing bad checks.
Whetsel said a number of Minnesota coin dealers called pitching deals, and he finally agreed to a $48,800 trade offered by Reputable Rare Coins. This time, Whetsel said, he got nothing at all.
"I don't think I'll ever get anything out of it," he grumbled. "I'm not buying any more coins, I can tell you that."
The firm's owner, Tory Hughes, had prior felony convictions related to drugs, forgery, theft and receiving stolen property. Local and federal authorities are investigating, but Hughes has not been charged. He could not be reached for comment.
Echoes of FDR
Many coin firms play on history by warning prospects that the government could seize their gold.
In 1933, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt signed an executive order requiring the liquidation of most privately held gold, with compensation paid in greenbacks. The order exempted "rare" or "collectible" coins and metals used in dentistry and jewelry.
The limitations on private gold ownership were lifted in 1975. But many coin firms foment fear of another "confiscation" as they pressure consumers to buy historic or commemorative coins.
Esther Lass, 84, of Grand Haven, Mich., said that was the pitch she heard from Michael Duff McNamara III, then with International Rarities. Lass said he convinced her that the government might seize her gold and that she should send it to him so he could swap it for collectible coins.
"I did, and that's the last I ever heard of him," Lass said.
After repeated attempts to reach McNamara over several weeks, he responded Friday and said it was up to the company to ship the coins and that if they weren't shipped, it wasn't his fault.
Lass said she originally got the coins from Barber Coin and Collectibles in Lakeville, but didn't want to go back there because she believes the firm shortchanged her on an earlier trade.
The company's attorney, Daryl Bergmann, said he investigated her claim in 2008 and found no irregularities. The prices for each coin were based on market prices at the time, he said.
Lass said she wrote to the Minnesota attorney general's office but was told it couldn't help. Her son, an attorney in New York, told her that without a written contract she didn't have a case, so she dropped the matter. In the end, Lass said she took a loss on her transaction with International Rarities.
"I claimed it last year on my income tax," she said. "Put their asses all in jail or send them straight to hell!"
Coin dealers court prospective clients as if they're old friends. The consumers often have no idea they might be getting ripped off. Sometimes, the frauds aren't discovered until they die and their heirs open their safe-deposit boxes.
Linda Keith said McNamara befriended her 85-year-old father last year by taking him out for meals and visiting him at his home. By then, McNamara had become managing director of Barber Coin, also known as BCC Precious Metals.
Keith's dad had suffered a stroke in 1999. A seizure in October 2009 left him with memory and reasoning impairments, she said. His problems gradually worsened until he was hospitalized for two weeks in December as he recovered from cerebral bleeding.
Keith filed a lawsuit last month against Barber Coin, its president, Leonard Barber Jr., vice president of sales Robert Boyd and McNamara alleging that they cheated her father, a vulnerable adult, out of at least $65,768. The newspaper agreed not to name her father, who has a different surname, because he has cognitive impairments.
McNamara, 56, is a fast talker who invokes religion in his sales pitch. He has been convicted of check forgery, possessing counterfeit checks, theft and driving under the influence, but it hasn't stopped him from working at several Twin Cities coin dealers. He now is managing director at International Gold & Silver Exchange in downtown Minneapolis.
"I'm in recovery. I've got three years clean," McNamara said.
After he left BCC in June, Keith said in her lawsuit, Boyd took over her dad's account and began "repositioning" his holdings, first selling gold and buying silver, then reversing the process.
Keith says her parents built their own home and never carried a mortgage until last year. Then she alleges that Boyd persuaded her dad to withdraw just over $174,000 from a reverse mortgage to buy more coins.
He bought some at huge markups, Keith's complaint says. For instance, she alleges that BCC sold him an 1862 half-dollar for $18,000 that appraisers valued at $4,000.
While Keith's father was in the hospital, BCC initiated transactions to convert some of her parents' gold in an individual retirement account to silver, the suit says. Her parents denied "knowingly" authorizing that.
Bloomington police say an investigation is pending. Boyd declined to comment.
McNamara said he conducted one transaction with Keith's father and gave him a good deal. He said what happened after that, though, "was absolutely atrocious." He said he's cooperating with police.
"I do have ethics and I do not believe in taking advantage of people, especially the elderly," McNamara said.
Bergmann, Barber's attorney, issued a statement saying Keith's accusations appear to be based on "suspicion and misinformation." He said BCC, Barber and Boyd are cooperating with police.
"I know some things look bad. He's got some employees who had some bad records," Bergmann said. But he said he expects Barber to prevail.
Bill Voss, a Texas lawyer helping victims of coin fraud, says the fallout from coin rip-offs is only beginning. With prices near record levels, coin companies are popping up left and right and people are buying.
But eventually, he said, they'll want to sell.
"When they start realizing that what they bought, they shouldn't have bought, and that they bought it way too high ... I think there's going to be a major, major problem."
The Voss Law Firm, P.C. represents clients on a local, national and international basis. We proudly serve companies and individuals along the Gulf Coast and around the globe on a contingency fee basis. Our law firm collects nothing unless we recover on our client's behalf.